Plants and indoor air
Plants and people

Do houseplants clean the air? What the research shows, and what does

The NASA chamber study read for what it measured, the number of plants a room would need, what EPA says, the wellbeing studies with their sizes and limits, and the remedies that do change indoor air.

Start here Essentials

At minimum this chapter asks you to read what the research measured, then pick one step that does change the air in your home. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.

  1. Read what the NASA chambers measured: one plant in a sealed box, high doses, 24 hours (What the NASA study measured).
  2. Read the plants-per-square-meter figure a home would need to match ordinary air exchange (How many plants a room would need).
  3. If air quality is your reason for plants, name one air step: source control, ventilation or a cleaner sized for the room (What does change indoor air).
  4. Keep plants for the reasons the wellbeing studies support, and keep the mix from staying soggy (The wellbeing studies, the plant's own air risk).

Minimum time: about 30 minutes to read, 10 more to write the step down. Done when: you can say in one sentence what a houseplant does and does not do for your air, and you have written down the one air step (source, ventilation or a sized cleaner) that fits your home.

1. What the NASA study measured Understand

Most "air-purifying plant" lists trace back to one report: Interior Landscape Plants for Indoor Air Pollution Abatement, written by B.C. Wolverton, Anne Johnson and Keith Bounds and dated September 15, 1989 (NASA technical memorandum 101766). It is a real study, and it found something real. It also measured something much narrower than the lists say, so it is worth reading for what it did.

The setup

The report tested plants in sealed chambers: closed Plexiglas boxes with no air coming in or out, so that any drop in a chemical's concentration inside could be credited to whatever was in the box. NASA's chambers measured 0.76 by 0.76 by 0.76 m and 0.76 by 0.76 by 1.53 m, about 0.44 and 0.88 cubic meters. That is the size of a small cupboard. Each chamber held one plant, in its nursery pot and soil, under constant grow lights (the report gives 125 to 150 foot-candles) with a small internal fan to mix the air.

The researchers injected one of three volatile organic compounds (VOCs: carbon-based chemicals that evaporate at room temperature, given off by paints, solvents, furnishings and fuels): benzene, trichloroethylene or formaldehyde. Each test ran 24 hours, with samples at 0, 6 and 24 hours. In the first year the doses were 15 to 20 parts per million (ppm), which the authors themselves describe as far above the levels common indoors. In the second year they used doses under 1 ppm for benzene and trichloroethylene.

Two controls ran beside the plants: an empty sealed chamber, to measure leaks, and pots of potting soil with no plant, to measure what the soil did by itself.

What it found

The concentration of each chemical fell over 24 hours. Some figures from the low-dose benzene runs, as the report gives them:

Chamber contentsBenzene removed in 24 hoursWhat it shows
English ivy89.8 percent (0.235 to 0.024 ppm)A plant in a sealed box lowers the chemical
Peace lily79.5 percentSame
Potting soil, no plant20.1 percentThe soil does part of the work on its own
Empty chamber5.3 percentA little is lost to leaks and surfaces

The report also cut the leaves off some plants and tested again. A Dracaena 'Janet Craig' removed 79.1 percent with its foliage and 45.2 percent without it; a golden pothos removed 67.2 percent with and 64.6 percent without. From results like these the authors concluded that the "plant root-soil zone" did most of the work, and they recommended leaving the soil exposed. For trichloroethylene at low dose, the plants removed 9.2 to 23.0 percent against 9.2 percent for soil alone.

The same report tested a fan that pulled air through activated carbon with a golden pothos growing in it, at 15 to 30 cubic feet per minute, and its summary says filters like that should be part of any plant-based plan. In other words, the report's own authors moved air through the root zone with a fan. A pot on a shelf has no fan.

What it did not say

  • No plants-per-room advice. The figure "one plant per 100 square feet", often credited to NASA, is not in the report. Its text contains no recommendation of plants per floor area.
  • No home or office test. Every result came from a sealed box of under one cubic meter. A room has air coming in and going out all the time.
  • No claim about space stations, shuttles or astronauts' air. The tests ran at NASA's Stennis Space Center, Mississippi.

One more fact belongs beside the results. The study was jointly funded by NASA's Office of Commercial Programs and the Associated Landscape Contractors of America, a trade association whose members install plants in buildings. The twelve plants screened are called "ALCA plants" in the report. Industry funding does not make a measurement wrong, but it is part of reading any study, and the report says so plainly on its own pages.

Physical principle A sealed chamber is the right tool for asking "can this plant take up this chemical?" It cannot answer "does this plant change the air in my room?", because a room's air is replaced from outside many times faster than one plant removes anything. The next section puts numbers on that.

Go deeper

The chamber method in more detail. The report's chambers had a chilled-water coil to hold temperature (its Table 4 gives 30 °C, plus or minus 1, at 125 foot-candles, plus or minus 5), and results are reported two ways: micrograms removed per plant, with the plant's leaf area (Tables 1 to 3), and percent removed (Tables 4 to 8). The first-year high-dose runs were sampled differently from the second-year low-dose runs, which used gas chromatography. The authors noticed soil bacteria counts rising with repeated benzene exposure in one Chinese evergreen test, where removal rose from 47.6 to 85.8 percent over six weeks, but they also wrote that the correlation was not consistent.

Leaves or roots? NASA's authors credited the root and soil zone. Two later reviews, Dela Cruz and colleagues in 2014 (abstract on PubMed) and Pettit, Irga and Torpy in 2018 (abstract on PubMed), say the studies since then disagree on which mechanism matters most. Dela Cruz's review adds that removal in the laboratory depends on the species, the light and the concentration of the chemical, and that in some studies more light meant more removal.

2. How many plants a room would need

In 2019 two researchers at Drexel University, Bryan Cummings and Michael Waring, asked the question the chambers could not: if you put the chamber results into the units used for air cleaners, how do plants compare with the air exchange a building already has? Their paper is titled, bluntly, "Potted plants do not improve indoor air quality" (Cummings and Waring, Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology). We read its abstract; the full text is behind a paywall.

The unit: clean air delivery rate

Clean air delivery rate (CADR) is the volume of air, per hour, from which a device removes a pollutant completely. A CADR of 100 cubic meters per hour means the device does the same job as replacing 100 cubic meters of the room's air with clean air every hour. It is the figure printed on portable air cleaners, so it lets a plant and a machine be compared on one scale.

Cummings and Waring reviewed 12 published chamber studies and converted 196 experimental results to CADR. A single plant's CADR spanned orders of magnitude between studies. The median (the middle value, with half the results above and half below) was 0.023 cubic meters per hour per plant.

The comparison: air exchange

Every building already has a way of removing indoor pollutants: outdoor air leaking or blown in, and indoor air leaving. The air exchange rate is how many times an hour that replaces a volume of air equal to the room's. The review takes about one exchange per hour as typical of buildings.

The result: to match the removal that ordinary air exchange already provides, a building would need 10 to 1,000 plants per square meter of floor. A square meter is a bit under 11 square feet, about the floor area of a small armchair. Even the low end of that range is ten pots on every square meter of every room.

Physical principle The arithmetic is why the chamber results and the home results do not conflict. A plant can take a chemical out of a sealed box of under one cubic meter over a day. A room exchanging its air once an hour moves its whole volume past that plant every hour, so the plant's contribution is small against the air that is already being replaced.

What other reviews add

Cummings and Waring are not the only reviewers, and some reviews read more favorably. The favorable ones mostly summarize chamber results; where they look at real rooms, they find little.

  • Few real-room studies. Dela Cruz's 2014 review says studies in real offices and homes are few and show mixed results.
  • A wide spread. A 2026 systematic review of 43 studies on benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylene found reported removal ranging from minus 25 percent to 100 percent, and its authors say practical use is constrained by the limited effect per plant, often needing large numbers of plants (Hamidianfar and colleagues, abstract on PubMed).
  • Mixed designs. Han and Ruan's 2020 review of 95 articles reports lower pollutant levels, then higher humidity and lower temperature, as the main effects found (abstract on PubMed). Its abstract does not compare those effects with ventilation, and it pools chamber and field designs, so it does not answer the room-scale question.
  • The research group that reported benefits moved on. Pettit, Irga and Torpy, from the University of Technology Sydney group whose earlier office work is often quoted for plants, wrote in 2018 that the potted-plant findings came largely from chamber experiments, and argued that active botanical biofilters (systems with a fan that pulls air through a planted growing medium) are the more effective route, still needing research to confirm.
Go deeper

The industry-funded office trial. The real-office study most often quoted for "a few plants are enough" was reported in a 2004 Nursery & Garden Industry Australia newsletter, funded by the nursery industry levy and the Australian government (Using pot plants to clean indoor air, Nursery Papers 2004). It put three or six floor-standing Dracaena 'Janet Craig', or six table plants, in 34 single-person offices of 10 to 12 square meters in three Sydney buildings, for runs of 5 to 9 weeks, and read total VOCs (TVOC) weekly with portable monitors.

  • With floor plants, planted offices were "up to 50 to 70 percent" lower in TVOC, but only in the weeks when unplanted offices were above 100 parts per billion (9 of 18 weeks). Three plants did as well as six.
  • With table plants, TVOC in planted offices was generally a bit higher than in unplanted ones; the newsletter attributes this to the flowering peace lilies.
  • The newsletter records outdoor carbon dioxide of 170 to 248 ppm, below the atmosphere's level at the time, which raises questions about the monitors. It gives no statistics beyond these figures.

We read it as a field result worth knowing about, from a promotional publication, with a measurement problem in its own table. It does not overturn the CADR comparison.

A review that misdescribes the source. A 2023 systematic review by Kumar and colleagues concludes that plants and their microbes "can be key solutions" (Kumar and colleagues, Air Quality, Atmosphere and Health). Its introduction describes the NASA work as a 1980 study in space shuttles. The report is a 1989 study in sealed chambers at Stennis Space Center. We show this as an example of how to read a review: a review is only as good as its reading of the papers it cites, and a claim repeated often enough starts to describe a study that did not happen the way it says. When a source makes a claim about plants and air, open the study it cites and look at the setup.

A comparison of scale, with a caveat. EPA's guide to air cleaners suggests a portable cleaner with a CADR of at least 65 cubic feet per minute for a 100 square foot room with an 8 foot ceiling. Physical principle One cubic foot per minute is about 1.7 cubic meters per hour, so 65 is about 110 cubic meters per hour. At the review's median of 0.023 cubic meters per hour per plant, that is about 4,800 plants. The two figures are not like for like: EPA's CADR rates particles, and the review's plant figure is for VOCs. The sum shows the scale of the gap, not a measured equivalence.

Carbon dioxide and humidity. Physical principle Plants take up carbon dioxide in light and give off water vapor, and claims about both circulate. We found studies on houseplants and carbon dioxide only as search results and could not read their full text, so this chapter gives no figure for either. Han and Ruan's review lists higher humidity among reported effects without a size we can quote. A hygrometer in your own room is the reading that matters (Humidity, temperature and the seasons).

3. What EPA says, and the plant's own air risk

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency answers the houseplant question directly, in two places.

  • On its main indoor air page, EPA notes the publicity about laboratory experiments and says there is currently no evidence that "a reasonable number of houseplants remove significant quantities of pollutants" in homes and offices (EPA, Improving Indoor Air Quality, last updated August 3, 2026).
  • In its technical summary on residential air cleaners, EPA calls potted plants "ineffective and impractical" for removing pollutants, because there is no active airflow and the number of plants needed is not feasible in most settings (EPA, Residential Air Cleaners: A Technical Summary, 3rd edition, 2018). It cites Dela Cruz's review among its sources, and leaves potted plants and plant walls out of its table of air-cleaning technologies. It adds that coatings and powered plant walls "have shown some promise" but are not widely available, and research on them remains limited.

So the agency position and the CADR review agree: plants take chemicals out of sealed boxes, and at any number a home can hold they do not measurably clean its air.

Limits

This chapter makes no health claim for you or anyone in your home. Houseplants are not a treatment for asthma, allergies, stress or any other condition, and we do not say keeping them will improve or harm your health. For indoor air concerns, EPA's guidance is the reference this chapter uses. For symptoms (coughing, wheezing, headaches, anything you think is linked to the air at home), a doctor is the person to ask, not this page.

The plant's own air risk: damp mix

EPA's indoor air page says one more thing about houseplants: do not overwater them, because damp soil may promote the growth of microorganisms (molds and bacteria) that can affect people with allergies. That is the one indoor air effect a houseplant has that an agency names, and it runs the other way from the lists.

It is also the thing a plant owner controls. Watering after a check, letting water drain, and emptying the saucer keeps mix from staying soggy for days; Watering by observation sets out the check, and Pots and potting mix the drainage. We found no allergy society page on houseplant soil and mold, so we say only what EPA says. Whether a particular person reacts to a particular plant's mix is a question for that person's doctor.

Potting mix carries a separate risk when you handle it, which Plants, pets and children covers: the Australian health departments name a bacterium, Legionella longbeachae, in potting mix dust.

4. What does change indoor air

EPA gives three strategies for better indoor air, in this order (EPA, Improving Indoor Air Quality). None of them is a plant.

StrategyWhat it meansWhat EPA says about it
Source controlRemove the thing giving off the pollutant, or reduce what it gives offUsually the most effective way; for most home problems, the most effective solution
VentilationBring in outdoor air and send indoor air outOpen windows and doors when weather permits; window or attic fans; kitchen and bathroom fans that exhaust outdoors; especially while painting, stripping paint, using a kerosene heater, cooking, soldering or sanding
Air cleaners and filtrationPass air through a filter that catches pollutantsEffectiveness depends on how much the filter catches and how much air it moves; most table-top models are much less effective; most are not designed to remove gases

Source control

Source control is dealing with where the pollutant comes from, so less of it gets into the air. Convention EPA lists it first and calls it usually the most effective way. For example, a can of solvent that is closed and kept out of the living room gives off less into that room than an open one on the shelf beside the sofa, and a product you do not buy gives off nothing.

Ventilation

Ventilation is replacing indoor air with outdoor air. In a home that is an open window, a kitchen or bathroom fan that vents outdoors, or a window air conditioner with its vent open, the examples EPA gives. A range hood that blows air back into the kitchen does not vent outdoors, so it is not ventilation in EPA's sense. It is the remedy EPA names for activities that release a burst of pollutants: run the fan or open the window while you do the job, not after.

A portable air cleaner, sized for the room

EPA's guide to air cleaners says to choose a portable cleaner by its CADR for the room it serves (EPA, Guide to Air Cleaners in the Home, last updated October 1, 2026). Its table of minimum CADR, for rooms with an 8 foot ceiling:

Room area (square feet)Minimum CADR (cubic feet per minute)
10065
200130
300195
400260
500325
600390

Product-specific CADR rates particles only. For gases, EPA points to activated carbon, and says there is no widely used rating system for how well a cleaner removes gases. EPA also says to avoid air cleaners that produce ozone on purpose. On health, EPA's guide says portable cleaners with HEPA filters (high-efficiency particulate air filters) "possibly" help heart, lung, allergy and asthma outcomes, with small improvements. We pass that on as EPA's own hedged wording, not as a promise for your home.

Furnace and air-handler filters

If your home has forced-air heating or central air, the filter in the system is already a filter for the whole home. EPA's guide suggests a filter rated at least MERV 13, or as high as the system can take. MERV (minimum efficiency reporting value) is a filter rating; EPA says filters at MERV 13 and above must remove at least 50 percent of the smallest particles tested. Ask the authority EPA's advice is conditional on what the system can take, so whether yours takes a MERV 13 filter is a question for the system's manual, its maker or a heating technician. In a rented home, the owner or manager decides what goes in the system.

Where plants fit. None of these steps involves a plant, and none is harmed by having plants. Keep the plants for what they do (the next section), keep their mix from staying wet (the plant's own air risk), and take the air step separately.

5. Plants and how people feel: the wellbeing studies

If plants do not clean a home's air, is there anything to the sense that a room with plants feels better? A body of research asks this, and it is a different question from air: it measures people, not pollutants. It is also small. We give each study's size and design so you can weigh it yourself.

Three studies, with their sizes and limits

StudyWho and how manyWhat was comparedWhat it foundLimits
Lee and colleagues, 201524 healthy young men, average age about 2515 minutes repotting a small peperomia against 15 minutes of computer word processing, on different daysMeasures of sympathetic nervous activity (the "stress" branch) rose during the computer task and fell by the end of the repotting; diastolic blood pressure was lower after repotting; participants rated themselves more comfortable and relaxedOne narrow group; effects showed only at the end of the 15 minutes; it compares plant work with computer work, not plants with no plants
Park and Mattson, 200990 patients recovering from one kind of surgery (hemorrhoidectomy)Hospital rooms with live plants and flowers against rooms withoutLower systolic blood pressure and lower ratings of pain, anxiety and fatigue, and higher room satisfaction, in plant roomsShort-term; partly self-rated; patients could see the plants, so they could not be blinded; the abstract does not report length of stay or pain medication as different
Han, Ruan and Liao, 2022 (meta-analysis)42 studies reviewed; 16 pooledObjectively measured outcomes (devices, tasks, exams) with and without plantsLower diastolic blood pressure and better academic achievement in pooled results; no significant effect on brain-wave measures, attention or response timeEach pooled analysis used only two or three studies; the blood pressure result had very high heterogeneity; most studies were not randomized and could not be blinded

Sources: Lee and colleagues, Journal of Physiological Anthropology; Park and Mattson, abstract on PubMed; Han, Ruan and Liao, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.

Reading terms in these studies

  • A randomized crossover study gives every participant both conditions in a random order, so each person is compared with themselves. Lee's study is one; it controls for differences between people but not for how the two tasks differ apart from the plant.
  • A meta-analysis pools the results of several studies into one estimate. It is only as strong as the studies it pools and how alike they are.
  • Heterogeneity is how much the pooled studies disagree with each other. Han's blood pressure analysis reports an I2 of 97.6 percent, which means almost all the spread between studies came from real differences between them rather than chance; a single pooled number hides that.
  • A standardized mean difference (SMD) is a size of effect expressed in standard deviations, so studies with different scales can be pooled. Han's blood pressure result is an SMD, not millimeters of mercury, so it does not mean "plants lower blood pressure by 2.5 points."

What we take from them

The studies point one way: people near plants, or working with them, tended to score lower on stress measures and rate a room more favorably. They are also small, short, often unblinded, and in narrow groups. The editors of a 2024 collection of papers on the subject, one of them an author of the meta-analysis, called research on indoor plants specifically "relatively limited" compared with research on nature in general (Han and colleagues, Frontiers in Psychology, 2024).

Preference Our reading: if you like having plants, the research does not argue against it, and some of it is consistent with how you feel about them. That is a reason to keep plants. It is not a finding that plants will lower your stress, and we do not offer it as one.

Go deeper

A workplace study with heavy dropout. The 2024 editorial summarizes a before-and-after study by de Vries and colleagues in nine Dutch organizations: 594 workers at the start, 254 at the roughly three-month follow-up, 128 at the four-month-plus follow-up. Complaints about dry air fell and ratings of privacy and workspace attractiveness rose at the first follow-up; health-related complaints at work fell and workspace satisfaction rose at the second. With fewer than a quarter of the starting group left at the end, the people who stayed may differ from those who left.

A government guideline, cited secondhand. Han's 2022 paper reports that South Korea's Rural Development Administration suggests one small and one large potted plant per 6 square meters to improve indoor quality. We have only Han's report of it, not the agency's own page, and it is not consistent with the CADR comparison for air. We list it so you recognize it if you meet it.

What earlier reviews found. Han's 2022 paper summarizes an earlier narrative review of 104 articles as finding gains in comfort and satisfaction but no strong evidence for performance and productivity. Two other frequently cited studies on plants and attention or pain tolerance we could not read beyond search results, so we leave them out.

6. See it See it

Fictional example

Marcus's six plants and his January air. Marcus (fictional) lives in a ground-floor apartment with forced-air heating. He has six plants: a peace lily, a spider plant, a fiddle-leaf fig, a Boston fern in the north bedroom, a Monstera and a ZZ plant. In January his hygrometer read 24 percent humidity, and he wondered whether more plants would help the air and the dryness.

Known: six plants; forced-air heat; the 24 percent reading. Assumed (ours, for the arithmetic): that the review's median figure of 0.023 cubic meters per hour per plant applies to his plants, though it comes from sealed chambers. Open: his apartment's floor area, which a tape measure or his lease settles; and whether his furnace takes a MERV 13 filter, which the system's manual, its maker or the building's owner settles.

The floor area does not change the answer. At the review's low end of 10 plants per square meter, a single square meter of his floor would need more plants than he owns in total. Under these assumptions his six plants make no measurable difference to his air, and more of them would not either. On the dryness, no source we could read gives a figure for how much a few pots raise a room's humidity, so his hygrometer, read again after any change, is the test (Humidity, temperature and the seasons).

His air step: forced-air heat means a filter already runs through the whole apartment, so he finds the filter, reads its rating, and asks whether the system takes MERV 13. If it does not, a portable cleaner sized by EPA's table for the room he uses most is the next option. He keeps the six plants because he likes them, and he checks that the fern's saucer is not left full, since the bedroom is where he sleeps.

7. Practice: one air step for your home Practice

Minimum: one sentence on what your plants do and do not do for your air, and one air step written down. Time: about 20 minutes, plus a tape measure's worth of a room. Materials: a tape measure, your heating or cooling system's filter slot (if you have one), and the room sheet in your plant file or a piece of paper.

  1. Write the one-sentence answer. In your own words: what a houseplant does for air in a sealed chamber, and what EPA and the CADR review say it does in a home. If you can say it without the words "purify" or "clean", you have it.
  2. List what gives off fumes in the room you use most. Solvents, paints, cleaning products, fuel-burning appliances, a gas stove. For each, ask whether it can be closed, moved or vented. That is source control.
  3. Find your ventilation. Which windows open, whether the kitchen and bathroom fans vent outdoors, and which jobs you will run them for.
  4. Find your filter, if you have forced air. Read the rating printed on its frame. Write down the size and rating, and the question for the system's maker or owner: does it take MERV 13?
  5. If you are considering a portable cleaner, measure the room's floor area and read the minimum CADR from EPA's table. Write it beside the room on the room sheet. The table assumes an 8 foot ceiling; for a taller room, read EPA's guide or ask the cleaner's maker how to size it.
  6. Check the saucers. Any saucer holding water an hour after watering gets emptied, so mix does not stay wet (how much to water).
Go deeper

Read one claim back to its source. Find any page or plant tag that says a plant purifies air or cites NASA. Note what it claims (a number of plants, a list of chemicals, "per 100 square feet"). Then open the NASA report and look for the same claim. Write down whether the report's setup (a sealed chamber under one cubic meter, one plant, 24 hours) supports it. This is the same check we used on the 2023 review.

8. Your plants Your plants

9. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Can you say what the NASA study measured: one plant, a sealed chamber under one cubic meter, high doses in its first year, 24 hours?
  • Can you give the review's range of plants per square meter needed to match ordinary air exchange, and say what it is compared with?
  • Does your one-sentence answer avoid saying plants clean or purify a home's air?
  • Have you named one air step that fits your home (source control, ventilation, a filter rating or a sized cleaner) and written down who answers any open question about it?
  • If you keep plants for wellbeing, can you say what the studies measured and how small they were, without turning them into a promise?
  • Are your saucers emptied, so the mix does not stay soggy?

Worked example

Priya (fictional) works at an office desk about 20 feet from the nearest window and chose a ZZ plant for it. Her one sentence: "A plant can take some chemicals out of a sealed box, but EPA and the review say it does not measurably clean a room's air, so my ZZ plant is there because I want a plant." Her air step is not hers to take: an office building's ventilation and filters belong to its facilities team, so she writes the question down for facilities and leaves it there. Against the criteria, her sentence holds, her air step names who settles it, and she makes no wellbeing promise to herself, only a preference. The one thing she does control is watering the ZZ plant after a check, so its mix does not sit wet.

Common mistakes

  • Counting plants per room for air. The "one plant per 100 square feet" figure is not in the NASA report, and the review's figures are ten to a thousand times higher per square meter. Any plant count chosen for air is a count for something else.
  • Reading chamber percentages as room percentages. "Removed 89.8 percent" happened in a sealed box under one cubic meter, over 24 hours. A room's air is replaced long before a plant could do the same.
  • Buying a cleaner by the box's room claim. Read the CADR and compare it with EPA's table for the room's area, and remember CADR rates particles, not gases.
  • Treating the wellbeing studies as a dose. They were 15 minutes of repotting, or days in a hospital room, in small groups. They do not tell you how many plants or how long.
  • Overwatering for "humidity". A wet pot is the one air effect EPA names for houseplants, and it is a bad one for people with allergies.

What is still unresolved

  • Whether your heating system takes a MERV 13 filter: its manual, its maker, a heating technician, or the building's owner.
  • Any symptom you connect with the air at home: a doctor.
  • Your home's actual humidity and how plants and a humidifier change it: Humidity, temperature and the seasons, with a hygrometer.
  • Which of your plants are toxic to a pet or child: Plants, pets and children and Plants, one by one.
  • Whether powered plant walls work in homes: EPA calls the research limited, and we found no home test to cite.

10. Knowledge check and scenario

The NASA report's English ivy removed 89.8 percent of benzene in 24 hours. Why does that not mean an ivy removes most of the benzene in a living room?
The ivy sat alone in a sealed chamber of under one cubic meter with no air coming in or out, for 24 hours. A living room is many times larger and exchanges its air with outdoor air about once an hour, so the room's own air exchange removes far more than the plant does. Cummings and Waring's conversion puts the gap at 10 to 1,000 plants per square meter of floor to match it.
What did the NASA authors find when they cut the leaves off some plants?
Much of the removal remained (Janet Craig 79.1 percent with leaves, 45.2 percent without; pothos 67.2 and 64.6 percent). They concluded the root and soil zone did most of the work, and the soil-only control removed 20.1 percent of benzene by itself. Later reviews say studies disagree on the mechanism.
A friend says a 300 square foot room needs "a few good air-purifying plants." What would you suggest looking at instead, and where does the number come from?
First the sources of fumes in the room and whether it can be ventilated, which EPA lists first and second. If they want a cleaner, EPA's table gives a minimum CADR of 195 cubic feet per minute for 300 square feet with an 8 foot ceiling, for particles. Plants are not on EPA's list.
Han's meta-analysis found lower diastolic blood pressure with plants. Why can't you say plants lower blood pressure by 2.5 points?
The result is a standardized mean difference, a size in standard deviations, not millimeters of mercury. It pooled only three studies, with an I2 of 97.6 percent, meaning the studies disagreed strongly with each other. It is a pooled signal from a few small studies, not a dose for a reader.
(Go deeper) What two problems does the 2004 Sydney office trial have as evidence for a few plants per office?
Its lower TVOC readings appeared only in the weeks when unplanted offices were above 100 ppb, and table plants gave slightly higher TVOC overall; and its recorded outdoor carbon dioxide (170 to 248 ppm) was below the atmosphere's level at the time, which casts doubt on the monitors. It was also industry-funded and reported in a promotional newsletter without statistics.
Marcus's January hygrometer reads 24 percent, and a friend tells him to buy a dozen "air-purifying" plants for the dry, stuffy feel of the apartment. What should he do?
At 10 to 1,000 plants per square meter needed to match ordinary air exchange, a dozen pots do not change his air, and misting raises humidity only briefly, as Humidity, temperature and the seasons explains. More plants also mean more mix to keep from staying wet, which is the one air effect EPA names.
This uses the steps EPA lists: ventilation, then filtration, starting with the filter his forced-air system already runs. The humidity question stays open until he reads the hygrometer after any change; the filter question is settled by the system's manual, maker or owner.
A cleaner sized by its CADR for one room is a sound air step for particles, and EPA's guide supports it. It does nothing for humidity or gases unless it has carbon, and it costs more than checking the filter he already has.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.